California Court Rejects Jay-Z’s Attempt to Revive Lawsuit Against Tony Buzbee

A California appeals court has rejected Jay-Z’s attempt to revive his extortion and defamation lawsuit against Texas attorney Tony Buzbee, who previously represented a woman accusing the rapper of sexually assaulting her when she was 13. The allegations, which also named Sean Combs, were ultimately dismissed. In a unanimous 24-page ruling, California’s Second Appellate District concluded that Buzbee did not act with malice when he pursued the claims against Jay-Z, whose legal name is Shawn Carter.
Associate Justice Anne Richardson wrote that there was no evidence Buzbee knowingly made false accusations or acted with reckless disregard for their truth. Instead, the court said declarations submitted by Buzbee indicated that investigations conducted by his firm and a referral firm led him to believe the allegations were credible. The court also determined that Buzbee’s demand letter to Carter was protected by litigation privilege because a lawsuit was genuinely being contemplated in good faith.
Buzbee welcomed the ruling in a statement, arguing that sending a demand letter before filing a lawsuit does not constitute extortion. Carter filed his lawsuit against Buzbee in late 2024, alleging the attorney knew the accusations were false and had sent two demand letters seeking money to settle the matter privately. After Carter declined to participate, Buzbee publicly identified him as the previously unnamed defendant in the woman’s lawsuit. Carter’s appellate attorneys did not immediately respond to requests for comment.










